top of page

Breaking Bread with BRIC: Can We Disagree and Still Pass the Potatoes?

Writer: LaDawn Sullivan
LaDawn Sullivan
5 days ago
3 min read

Because everybody at the table doesn't have to think alike to belong.

Breaking Bread with BRIC graphic featuring a Black family gathered for dinner, a large bowl of mashed potatoes, and the headline “Can We Disagree and Still Pass the Potatoes?”

There was a time when family gatherings came with three guarantees: too much food, somebody arriving late, and at least one conversation that made everybody stop chewing.


You know the moment. Somebody says something about politics, religion, or how the world ought to work, and suddenly Auntie is gripping her fork like she's preparing to testify before Congress. Somebody else is rolling their eyes, and the person who started it all is asking, "What? I'm just saying!"


And somehow, we still managed to pass the potatoes, pack up leftovers, and tell everybody we loved them on the way out.


But lately, I've been wondering: Have we lost the ability to disagree without disconnecting?


I've spent enough time around family tables, community gatherings, and foundation boardrooms to know that five people can agree on the problem and come up with seventeen different solutions. And that's before somebody suggests forming a committee!


The challenge isn't that we disagree. It's that we've started treating disagreement as betrayal.


We've become quick to label, quicker to dismiss, and sometimes entirely too comfortable cutting people off rather than working through the discomfort of understanding them.


Now, don't misunderstand me. I'm not suggesting we tolerate disrespect, discrimination, or anyone questioning another person's humanity. There's a difference between a different perspective and a harmful belief.


Everybody deserves a seat at the table, but nobody gets a free pass to turn the table over.


Still, when our circles become so small that everyone thinks, votes, and believes exactly like we do, that's not necessarily community. Sometimes that's just an echo chamber with better food.


Through Breaking Bread with BRIC, we're encouraging families, friends, and neighbors to gather over good food and meaningful conversation. Not to convince everybody they're wrong and we're right, but to strengthen relationships and discover where our shared values can move us toward collective action.


Especially as elections approach, our tables will include different political perspectives, generational experiences, religious beliefs, and ideas about progress. Some believe change happens through policy, others through economic investment, community organizing, faith, or personal responsibility. Most of us know it takes a combination.


Unity does not require uniformity. Solidarity does not require silence. And love does not require agreement.


Building strong Black communities requires us to organize, invest, participate, vote, and act together. We cannot afford to let every difference become a division when so much of our collective future depends on one another.


So, as we continue Breaking Bread with BRIC through Thanksgiving, invite someone to the table whose perspective may differ from yours. Bring curiosity, a little humility, and enough patience to let somebody finish a sentence. Imagine that!


Not every disagreement needs a winner. Sometimes the victory is leaving with a little more understanding and the relationship still intact.


Because we don't have to agree on everything to agree that we need one another.


Now, somebody please pass the potatoes. They're getting cold.


Breaking Bread with BRIC: Table Talk Rules

A little food for thought!

  1. Come curious, not combative. Ask questions before making assumptions.

  2. Listen to understand. Not just to prepare your comeback.

  3. Disagree without disrespect. Challenge ideas, not someone's humanity.

  4. Share the microphone. Everybody gets a turn. Even Uncle Long-Winded!

  5. Find common ground. What do we care about enough to work on together?

  6. Leave with love and action. Agree on one thing you can do to strengthen your community.


The goal isn't to win the argument. It's to keep building community BRIC by BRIC


Comments


bottom of page